Lean vs Scrum: Which is Better for Project Management [2023]

In today’s fast-paced business environment, many companies are using Agile project management methods to help them better handle the complexity and change of projects. Agile methods include a variety of different approaches, and two of the most common are Scrum and Lean.

In this article, we will explore these two methods in depth and attempt to answer the question of “which method is better for project management.”

Scrum

What is Scrum?

Scrum is an iterative and evolutionary project management method. It divides projects into a series of small iterations, with each iteration completing specific tasks. After each iteration is completed, the team conducts evaluations and improvements, and adjusts the plan based on the progress of the project.

The core roles of Scrum include the Product Owner, Team Members, and Scrum Master.

For example, a software development team may use Scrum to build a new mobile app. They would divide the project into small iterations, with each iteration focused on completing a specific set of features. At the end of each iteration, the team would conduct a review to evaluate the progress and identify areas for improvement.

Who uses Scrum？

Scrum methods are commonly used to handle complex projects, such as software development and product design.

Its iterative and evolutionary approach is better able to adapt to changes in the project, and allows teams to complete projects more quickly.

Scrum methods have been widely applied in various industries, such as finance, healthcare, and technology. For example, a financial services company may use Scrum to develop a new trading platform. The team would divide the project into small iterations, with each iteration focused on completing a specific set of features.

By using Scrum, the team is able to quickly adapt to changes in the market and deliver value to the customer more quickly.

Lean

What is Lean?

Lean is a project management method aimed at improving efficiency by eliminating waste and optimizing processes. It is based on the principles of the Toyota Production System, and emphasizes the continuous flow of work and the reduction of waste.

The key roles in Lean include the Value Stream Manager, Team Members, and the Lean Coach. For example, a manufacturing company may use Lean to improve the efficiency of its assembly line.

The Lean team would identify areas of waste in the production process, such as unnecessary steps or bottlenecks, and implement changes to eliminate these waste areas. This would result in a more efficient and effective production process.

Who uses Lean?

Lean methods are commonly used in manufacturing and service industries. Its focus on continuous flow and waste reduction makes it well suited for industries where there are large volumes of repetitive work, such as assembly lines and call centers. Lean methods have been applied in various industries, such as automotive, healthcare, and finance.

For example, a call center may use Lean to improve the efficiency of its customer service process. The Lean team would identify areas of waste in the process, such as long wait times or unnecessary transfers, and implement changes to eliminate these waste areas. This would result in a more efficient and effective customer service process.

The Differences between Scrum and Lean

While Scrum and Lean seem to share many similarities, there are also some key differences between them. Scrum is more focused on iterative and incremental development, while Lean is more focused on continuous flow and waste reduction. Scrum uses a more flexible approach to planning, allowing for adjustments based on the progress of the project, while Lean uses a more structured approach, with a clear plan and schedule. Scrum emphasizes collaboration and communication within the team, while Lean emphasizes the alignment of the team with broader organizational goals.

For example, consider a company that is developing a new product. If the company uses Scrum, the team would focus on completing small iterations of the product, with frequent evaluations and improvements. This approach would allow the team to quickly adapt to changes in the market and customer needs. On the other hand, if the company uses Lean, the team would focus on optimizing the development process to eliminate waste and improve efficiency. This approach would allow the team to deliver the product more quickly and at a lower cost.

The Similarities of Scrum and Lean

Despite their differences, Scrum and Lean share the same principles of Agile project management, which both emphasize collaboration and communication within the team. Both methods also use frequent evaluations and improvements to ensure the success of the project. They also focus on delivering value to the customer, which usually needs cross-functional teams to accomplish.

For example, consider a team that is developing a new software application. Both Scrum and Lean would encourage the team to collaborate closely and communicate regularly. They also encourage the team to regularly evaluate the progress of the project and make improvements as needed. Besides, in the meantime, both methods also focus on delivering value to the customer by building features that meet their needs and expectations.

How to Choose Agile Methodology for Project Management?

When choosing an Agile methodology for project management, it is important to consider the specific needs and goals of the project.

If the project is complex and subject to frequent changes, Scrum may be a better option, as its iterative and evolutionary approach allows for more flexibility.

If the project involves large volumes of repetitive work, Lean may be a better option, as its focus on continuous flow and waste reduction can help improve efficiency.

Ultimately, the best approach will depend on the specific needs and goals of the project.

For example, consider a company that is developing a new e-commerce website. If the project is complex and subject to frequent changes, the company may choose to use Scrum. The team would divide the project into small iterations, with each iteration focused on completing a specific set of features. This approach would allow the team to quickly adapt to changes in the market and customer needs.

On the other hand, if the project involves large volumes of repetitive work, such as managing orders and processing payments, the company may choose to use Lean. The team would focus on optimizing the process to eliminate waste and improve efficiency. This approach would allow the team to deliver the website more quickly and at a lower cost.

Conclusion

In conclusion, Scrum and Lean are two popular Agile project management methods, each with its own strengths and weaknesses. Scrum is better suited for complex and changing projects, while Lean is better suited for projects with large volumes of repetitive work. Both methods are based on the principles of Agile project management and emphasize collaboration and communication within the team. The best approach will depend on the specific needs and goals of the project.

In addition to Scrum and Lean, there are many other agile methodologies to consider, such as Kanban, Extreme Programming (XP), and Dynamic Systems Development Method (DSDM). It is important to research and compare different agile methodologies to determine the best fit for your team and project.

To help teams and organizations fully and effectively implement Agile principles, especially for remote teams, VUCAC offers a convenient online whiteboard tool that allows for seamless collaboration and easy implementation of Scrum and Lean methodologies.

Sign up Free →